Saturday, November 20, 2010

Why (modern) arranged marriages fail?

Slow rate of decrease of men domination and high rate of increase of (pseudo) women liberation is a common factor for the increased failure of both love and arranged marriages! Discussing about that common factor is not the intent of this post.

 First of all, why do love marriages fail? What is positively said about love marriages is that the girl and boy already  get to know about each other and so they form a 'Perfect Match'. Even then, why do love marriages fail? Leave the cases where the trouble is created by some external forces. There are good amount of love marriage failures because of the mis-understanding between husband and wife. The whole idea behind love marriage, i.e 'Understanding' is in a shake.



Yes, the boy and girl 'get to know' about each other when they love. But what do they get to know is a big question.  Most of the lovers project only their positive side when they love. So the misunderstanding after marriage is because of 'not enough understanding' before marriage.

"Ok fine Karthik. The topic is about arranged marriage. But you are discussing about Love marriage???"

Yes I am coming to the topic now. The same problem, 'not enough understanding' has crept  into arranged marriages too. 'Pre marriage flirting' is what I am referring to. This started even before cell phone penetration. That time 'cordless phones' were helping. After the penetration of mobile phones, there is a multi-fold increase in flirting. (First of all, is it right to call the telephonic conversation between 'would be' husband and wife as flirting?). Getting the phone numbers and talking over phone (between engagement and marriage) is approved by parents (though with some murmurs).

A month back, I boarded Mysore-Chennai (via Bangalore,Kanchipuram) bus at Bangalore. The person in the next seat was a girl (I am still surprised how they allotted a male and female in adjacent seats. What was more surprising is that most of the seats in that bus were allotted in the same manner. Something wrong!).

She was already over phone. After hearing a minute of her conversation (things falling on our ears without our consent is not overhearing ;) ), I understood that she was talking with her future (who can assure about future?) husband. With more hearing, I realised that she is talking with him since she boarded her bus (at Mysore). Since I was not very comfortable in having a lady at the next seat (u know? I am a gentleman :P), I was not able to sleep comfortably. I was awake at least till the bus was crossing Vaniambadi (100 kms from Bangalore) and she was talking till then. When I left the bus at Kanchipuram, she was sleeping. So I am not sure, when they completed. Hope all of you have heard such conversations with ENTROPY = 0 :)

"Karthik, their phone, their battery, their money, their life. What's your problem?"

See I can't be selfish not thinking about others ;)

Just like lovers chat where only positives are projected, even in these Pre marriage flirting, only positives are projected both by the man and woman. She will try to project herself as a a best woman a family can get, so adjustable, so caring blah blah blah. He will try to project himself as an intelligent person, hero, highly humorous, person FOR women liberty blah blah blah.

When he/she sees the reality after marriage, which will definitely be different from what they were thinking, full disappointment. What is worse was the guy's projection about his mother as a caring lady who will treat his fiance as her daughter which will definitely be considered false by that girl after marriage (To know more, read 'in_laws'). If they think more and more about that disappointment, it will get bigger and bigger, thereby ending up in failure.



The idea behind pre (arranged) marriage conversations is to add the positive of love marriage (i.e understanding before marriage) to arranged marriage. The transition after marriage (esp for girls) will be somewhat smooth when they already have an idea about the better half's likes, dislikes, family etc. But when it becomes over-dosage, then it will definitely add the negative of love marriage also (i.e not enough understanding).

What is the moral? "Adakki Vaasi"


P.S: There is a bit of selfishness in this post. If some one see me doing too much of Pre marriage flirting after my engagement, please remind me about this post. Thanks in advance! ;)

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

Good post Karthi .. oru chinna doubt .. yenda why you are commenting on seat allocation and all in bus ???? .. unakku yenna problem anda ponnu unkitta pesalena .. seri vidu yennako , rajakarthi ko adu mathiri chance kadaikaliye nu irukkom ..

Karthik.R said...

@Anonymous comment a pottadhu yaru pa? per sollala na epdi?

AgentHunt said...

Hmm. Good analysis. This is one of the reasons why a marriage works or fails. But there are umpteen other (unexplainable and irrational) reasons on why a marriage can work or not work. And there is no magic formula for every marriage to work. There shouldn't be one also.

Even if you stay married and both of you are unhappy, what is the point of marriage working?

Besides, both should be mature enough to take a right decision that is the best interest of the each other and the families involved

Vinodh said...

Hi Karthik,

Good thought. Boy or girl should try to be themselves before and after marriage, instead of adding glamour in both stages, which is not there real nature.

If you talk to our parents you find they are so attached but they maintain dettachment before every body else........Aadaki Vaskiranga,

Instiution of Marriage remains the same for ages, expecting for adding new world gizmos and glamour which are really killing relationship instead of keeping them alive.

New gizmos really keeps people in touch, but relationship should touch each other's heart to catch the right signal so that relationship do not drop every second.

Cheers,
Vinodh

Karthik.R said...

@Shailesh (AgentHunt)

Thanks for the comments.

//There shouldn't be one also// I thought it would be great if there is one because families are the building molecules of our nation.

//Even if you stay married and both of you are unhappy, what is the point of marriage working?//
I call even this as failure (not just divorces).

Karthik.R said...

@Vinodh

//Boy or girl should try to be themselves//

Nice words!

Lucky said...

Nice Post!!!!

Then what about u? Going to have Love marriage or arranged one?

krishna said...

It's a very debateable topic. Pre-marriage flirting is a good term but what I feel is unless you know what to talk and what not to talk between engagement and marriage things can go smoother, well atleast. Talking about family sentiment and relatives is totally useless but that should be within limit too. "Yenga appa mari yarum kadayadhu", "yenga amma mari yarum vara mattanga" adhanalla nee avanga yenna sonnalum kaekanum, conversations like these can irritate both at some point. It's all about talking and getting to know only about each other well(both good and bad). Why should we( In general) give room for external forces to intrude by talking sentimental *hits*.

Karthik.R said...

@Lucky

Marriage arranged by me ;)

Karthik.R said...

@Krishna

Have a happy and safe flirting life machi ;)

Karthik Raja said...

@anonymous,

Yaaru pa nee, en paer use panni irukardhu?? but thanks for understanding my peelings ;-)

@karthi,

I guess it should be sriram jayakumar da..

Jil Jil Ramamani said...

Porukadhe :P

Master of None said...

Karthik, I came to your blog following the link for BJ's comment on IR (from Raj Sir's community). I am not sure the pre marriage flirting is a major cause for failure but yes it does add to it. What is happening in India at least from what I observe in couples around me is that Indian men regardless of how "forward", "non-chauvinistic" they consider themselves to be, are brought up in a very patriarchical sense. The recent trends of women being well educated and financially independent has brought about a change in their outlook and on the negative side, lowered their tolerance levels drastically. My mom can take a lot more shit than I can which in turn in more than what cousins half my age can. So the family dynamics is in a flux where the guy has to unlearn the patriarchical setup while the woman has to understand that independence does not necessarily mean lower tolerance towards loved ones. Sadly though, in many cases, this doesn't happen smoothly.

Nevertheless I enjoyed your post. Best wishes for your married life.

Karthik.R said...

@Vidya

//My mom can take a lot more shit than I can which in turn in more than what cousins half my age can//

In a more detailed way, you were trying to cover the 2nd half in my first line.

"Slow rate of decrease of men domination and high rate of increase of (pseudo) women liberation is a common factor".

Actually my aim was to highlight pre-marriage flirting. Putting it as a reason for failure of marriages will make it big and attract more readers ;) Cheap advertisement! :P

Nice that you enjoyed reading the post!

Karthik.R said...

//Best wishes for your married life//

Hope you were wishing for my marriage which might happen in future.

Just to clarify, naan ippo oru thanimaram.. kalyanam aana blog lam ezhudha mudiyuma nu theriyala.. samayal kattulerndhu karandi lam vandhu vizhum podhu system monitor crack aagidum la! :P